Kidnapped, Trafficked, Detained? The Implications of Non-state Actor Involvement in Immigration Detention

Michael Flynn
Global Detention Project

Credit: UN Photo/Marco Dormino

Kidnapped, Trafficked, Detained? The Implications of Non-state Actor Involvement in Immigration Detention

EXECUTIVE SUMMARY

Global migration challenges are reinforcing long-standing trends that involve shifting immigration control measures beyond national borders and incorporating new actors into detention systems. Proposals to shape migration management policies — including discussions on developing a Global Compact for Migration — recognize the need to involve a range of actors to implement humane and effective strategies. However, when observed through the lens of immigration detention, some policy trends raise challenging questions, particularly those that lead to increasing roles for non-state actors in migration control. This article critically assesses a range of new actors who have become involved in the deprivation of liberty of migrants and asylum seekers, describes the various forces that appear to be driving their engagement, and makes a series of recommendations concerning the role of non-state actors and detention in global efforts to manage international migration. These recommendations include:

  • ending the use the detention in international migration management schemes;
  • limiting the involvement of private companies in immigration control measures;
  • insisting that the International Organization for Migration (IOM) actively endorse the centrality of human rights in the Global Compact for Migration and amend its constitution so that it makes a clear commitment to international human rights standards; and
  • encouraging nongovernmental organizations to carefully assess the services they provide when operating in detention situations to ensure that their work contributes to harm reduction.

DOWNLOAD

Author Names

Michael Flynn

Journal Journal on Migration and Human Security
Date of Publication 2017
Pages 593-613
Volume 5
Issue Number 3

More...

Research Area:
Regions:
Publication Types: